<|-- removed generator --> The Online Photographer: Pleas and Thank Yous

« The Absolute Best Color Film | Main | TOP is 19! »

Wednesday, 27 November 2024

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I liked the David Christian video.

You are right that the big bang seems implausible. One way to see how weird it is is to think of another implausible thing: in the 1960s, Roger Penrose showed a remarkable thing: that the collapse of stars to form black holes was inevitable, and that this collapse continues until ... well, really until the laws of physics we understand no longer hold in the incredibly fierce conditions. This was a truly remarkable result, and I think very unexpected: before this people had assumed that black holes were just a toy thing that never really would happen.

Well, Stephen Hawking then did a brilliant trick: he took Penrose's theorem and showed that you could make a modified version of it which works backwards, and applies to the whole universe (this does not mean the universe is a black hole run backwards: it is more subtle than this). So if you run the whole universe backwards you inevitably get to a point where things become so fierce that the laws of physics we understand no longer work. Which is the big bang.

We physicists like to pretend that this was 'obvious' but that is not true: it seems deeply implausible ... but we have learned that God does not care about what we humans think is implausible, merely what must be.

(David Christian makes one small (but actually very big) error: he says the universe was initially very small ('smaller than an atom'). This is not what we currently think most likely. As best we can tell the universe is infinite in space: we are mot certain of this but measurements we can do show that is at least very close to the conditions needed for it to be infinite. Is a slight get-out here: it could be finite but wrapped around on itself. This case seems unlikely but people do look for evidence that it might be true.

If the universe is infinite in space it was infinite in space right back to the big bang. This becomes almost impossible to visualise! However, what is true is that the great majority of this infinite space is 'outside our past light cone' and the part of the universe we can see the history of was indeed very small close to the big bang.)

My initial reaction to Ellen Cushing's idea of adopting Canada's Thanksgiving date was: Brilliant! Aside from all the stuff you mentioned, it would actually let our bodies and minds recover from the T-day feasting, travel and family before the Christmas-go-round starts. As it is now, we hardly have a break between two travel- and family-intensive holidays. An extra month would be welcome. And, yes, having Thanksgiving overrun by a consumerist orgy sucks.

Watching a World Series baseball game instead of mid-season football might be more interesting, too.

On the other hand, it would mean that Thanksgiving coincides with the height of the US election campaign season. Do we really want that? Could it survive that? Could WE survive that?

Happy Thanksgiving! Not something we celebrate over here in Europe, but we are quickly adopting your tradition of enjoying a whole month of Black Friday week...

And of course Happy Birthday to TOP!

If I click on an Amazon link and then switch to the Canadian Amazon, will you still get a credit?

I absolutely loathe my favorite holiday, Thanksgiving, being commingled with the commercial side of Christmas. Thanksgiving can be enjoyed by folks of all stripes that feel thankful for something, and you get to celebrate the warmth with a shared meal, no gifts required. I would be fine with October, although that month now seems to be an excuse for 30 days of Halloween.

As for David Christian, perhaps the following link may be helpful:
https://www.ted.com/speakers/david_christian

30%? Wow. that's greedy of them.

You never beat your drum too hard.

And I wish I could still support you but as I've told you, I can't use Patreon. And because I don't live in the US, I can't use your links to order anything. I mean, I could. But you know what I mean. Cash is not an option either. What else?

But really, thanks for all you give us! Happy holidays!

That's a wonderful image by Kenneth Tanaka.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Portals




Stats


Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 06/2007