The comments are currently completely up to date.
Yesterday I alighted on what might be a better method for Yr. Hmbl. Moderator to keep up with comments: instead of writing a post first and then updating all the comments of a new morning, over my white tea, as has been my quotidian habit lo these very nearly 19 years (TOP turns 19 on the 28th of this month), I'm going to try switching the order around, and doing the comments first and then doing my writing.
That might help. I'll try it and see.
I will note, however, that the problem is not entirely mine. It is 97% me; I grant that. I am not dodging blame. (I am Hmbl., remember.) However, another aspect of it is that people are not commenting in as timely a fashion as they used to. More and more, readers are tending to visit not every day but every few days (if not every week or more) scrolling down to see if they find anything interesting. Formerly, when I had multiple tens of thousands of visitors every day (pause to sigh for Good Old Days), I would get a plethora of comments on a new post right away, from which I could extract the Featured Comments; and then I would just let go the good ones that came in late, because that saved me from having to add Featured Comments to days-old posts and getting all mixed up. Now, however, almost nothing comes in immediately, and I am left with the task of adding new Featured Comments to days-old posts, dealing with scattered comments on scattered posts. Which is greatly more confusing to Now-Brain (formerly Young-Brain) and flummoxes if not flusters the workflow. It was much easier to marshal comments when they were all together, and to work on only one published post at a time.
For example, I got a nice comment just yesterday morning from a reader named John about traveling with a Leica in China, left under the "Deathless Leica M Film Cameras Rebound" post—a post which today is a week old. It's an excellent comment, so I added it to the Featured Comments of that old post, even though relatively few regular readers will see it there, because you have already left that post in your rear-view mirror.
I'm not saying you shouldn't comment on old posts. You should do whatever is normal, convenient, and natural for you, and we shall continue to prize your droppings as you manifestly prize our'n. I shall, anyway. But that's part of the whole picture, and I just thought I'd mention it. Even though it looks like I am looking for an excuse.
—Mike the Mod.
Thought I’d help and leave this timely comment.
[Published in 36 minutes! …With special apologies for all the delays you’ve suffered, Jeff. —Mike]
Posted by: Jeff | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 10:31 AM
My comment on comment management. Do whatever works for you to make it timely, because the comments are just as important as the posts on the unique website of yours. I'm just as excited to read the comments as I am to read the original post, sometimes more so. Comments, and the way you manage them, are what makes TOP the best photo blog.
People will also be more likely to leave comments in a timely manner if they know they will see them soon.
Posted by: John Krumm | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 10:41 AM
More seriously… by the time I left the above comment, you had already moved on to not just one, but two new posts. Counterproductive.
[I published all three of today’s posts at the same time, more or less. Because the first two aren’t about photography. —Mike]
Posted by: Jeff | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 11:14 AM
I'm with John Krumm; keeping well up to date with the comments will mean more comments, and a good reason to come back soon. I've been bouncing in to check for comments and bouncing right back out again when they aren't there.
Posted by: Roger Bradbury | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 11:58 AM
I never see featured comments because I read your posts as they come out, and the comments aren’t there yet. Perhaps they can be featured as round-up posts?
Posted by: Will Duquette | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 12:08 PM
How about a dedicated "featured comments" post every Sunday (or whatever day), where you list all the new featured comments that were posted since the last featured comments post?
I do like seeing the featured comments, but I access your site via an RSS reader, so I only see the new posts pop up in my feed. So I rarely go back.
Doing it this way would bring attention two new feature comments, and drive traffic back to old posts.
Posted by: Aakin | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 12:53 PM
“[I published all three of today’s posts at the same time, more or less. Because the first two aren’t about photography. —Mike]”
People like to comment on all your posts. I think one post a day, regardless of topic, with timely comments, would lead to much better dialogue. And dialogue I think is the goal, if you truly believe that comments are as important as your posts. BTW, I’m not suffering at all; just trying to help you help yourself.
Posted by: Jeff | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 01:12 PM
I sympathize.
OTOH, there's something about the evanescence of post topics and comments that I don't much like. Nature of the beast; nothing to be done.
We are recently returned from seven weeks of travel to New England, Wales and Old England. Traveling and/or staying mostly with others, there was just too much going on to keep up with TOP, let alone comment.
Now, I regret that some of the older posts I've just caught up on are closed. Yeah, I know, no one will read new comment on old posts. And yet . . . I so much want to tell about the hidden photographic magic in the Olympus TG-6 (and 7) that I'm about to burst. \;~)>
Posted by: Moose | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 01:31 PM
Consider closing off comments after maybe three days?
Posted by: MikeR | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 02:10 PM
Mike,
Your post on Sunday Nov. 5, seemed to be the answer to your problem of multiple reply’s to various posts. Just pick a day when you can pick out the best comments? Not sure how everyone might feel if theirs is left out..
Posted by: Bob G. | Thursday, 09 November 2023 at 05:03 PM