<|-- removed generator --> The Online Photographer: Hahnel Cube Charger

« Three Cylinders | Main | Charge! »

Sunday, 03 November 2024

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Watson makes a charger with interchangeable plates as well. They make 2 different models one that charges 2 batteries and one that only charges 1. Both take the same plates. A nice feature of the 2 plate version is that you can install 2 different plates so if you want to charge your Sony and Panasonic batteries, you can do both at the same time.

The Watson charger has been around for a long time so there are Watson plates for just about every camera battery, even many that are for long discontinued cameras. The display on the charger gives useful information like the current state of charge in percent so you can stick a battery in the charger to check the charge even if the charger is not plugged in.

The 2 battery version is kind of expensive, but plates are really cheap. If you have too many different cameras (not naming any names but I know who I am), it really makes a lot of sense.

I have a lot of Fujifilm cameras and at least 6 have the still sealed up chargers left in the box, since I have two always plugged in chargers from my first couple of bodies ready to use.

I was however able to buy a second X-T3 body for a low price (actually cheaper than the lower end X-T30), when Fujifilm came out with the "X-T3 international", which was simply the camera without the charger... that I would not have even taken out of the box. I guess my opinion would be different if I didn't have any chargers.

I have the Hahnel charging cube and multiple plates…. but I have not used them for a long time. For me… for travel, they are too heavy and too awkward. I deliberately have 2 cameras which share the same battery (Sony A7rv and a6700). I bring the standard Sony charger with the power cable shortened to 6 inches. I also bring a Nitecore portable unit… which is powered via usb.. and can be used in a car, boat, hotel room. A big advantage is it can charge two batteries at the same time, doubly useful if doing so while driving or left in the car to charge while I am hiking, having lunch, etc.

https://photo.nitecore.com/product/usn3pro

I have talked to my local camera retailer, who tells me the Hahnel units are one of their bestsellers.

I work very hard to minimise what I need to pack when travelling. If travelling locally (ie within Ireland), then maybe the Hahnel units might work for me… but it is far heavier and bulkier than current setup.

Interesting, Manfrotto sells the exact charging cube as the Hahnel, using what appears to be the exact same plates. Manfrotto Pro Cube Professional Twin Charger on Amazon.

Isn’t the lack of chargers nowadays because of regulations and environmental reasons, esp. now that cameras can be charged via USB-c?

You'll probably notice that the Hahnel charger, like Watson and other third-party chargers, only has two contacts for the battery, while the original camera manufacturer chargers will have four or five. So, what are they missing? The most important one is the T contact, which stands for Temperature. Genuine batteries have a thermistor, a simple temperature sensor, which genuine chargers can read. Third-party batteries nearly always fake it with a fixed resistor that always reports the temperature is perfectly fine.

This means that if a genuine battery on a genuine charger starts heating up too quickly, it will be detected, and charging will be stopped to prevent thermal runaway. Third party chargers and batteries will just continue heating up until they catch fire and burst, shooting jets of flame several feet into the air. Is the convenience or cost savings worth the increased risk of burning your house down?

The Hahnel charger may be fine for home use, but it weighs a pound. My two-slot Fuji chargers weigh a little over 3 ounces. If I'm going on a long trip, I take a backup, both chargers and batteries. Seven ounces (with backup) vs. two-pounds (with backup.) The heavier chargers may be okay for car trips, not so much for overhead bins.

I'm currently planning a long trip for December-January. My older MacBook Pro has been replaced by a Mac Air. I'm taking two Fuji X-T5 bodies and some Sigma lenses instead of the Nikon Z bodies and lenses. All for the reduction in weight, which becomes important as you slide into your ninth decade.

A lot of more recent cameras ( 5 years or so) charge over USB. I’m just coming to the end of an overseas trip and I’ve run everything off a USB charger—phone, camera, watch, laptop and iPad. The only things that needed separate chargers were my toothbrush and razor!

Travel with just about any modern (contemporary) camera and all you have to bring is a USB cable for battery charging. All the current Leicas I own are able to charge the batteries in camera with just a universally available USB cable. And most good hotels have USB ports in the rooms. Slender cable versus a full pound of charger? I'll choose the cable.

Same with my Sigma fp. Same with the Panasonic S5s. Same with the Fuji GFX 50Sii. And the cables are dirt cheap. You probably have ten or so sitting in a drawer.

The Panasonic battery (DMW-BLC12) and the Leica battery (BP-DC12) that came with my Leica Q are both labeled as Made in China by Panasonic Energy Wuxi Energy Co., Ltd.

I have several Panasonic Lumix DMW-BLC12 batteries I use in the Leica Q.

The equivalent Sigma battery is BP-51.

Initially I was really annoyed that my OM1 arrived without a charger - I was skeptical that charging with the cord would be practical so I did buy an aftermarket charger “just in case”. It turns out that it’s very practical to charge via the provided cable. There are some aftermarket batteries that charge directly via cable - the companies would do everyone a service by adopting that method, making charging easier and reducing waste.

I’m sick of taking old charges and other e-junk to the recycling center.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Portals




Stats


Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 06/2007